By Dr. Kamal Alhallak, PhD | Part 6 of 10
The Alberta Court of Appeal used the expression “double-bind” to describe a part of my experience with the College. As I defended my qualifications and practice, that defence could reinforce allegations about how I had responded to the investigation. The Court upheld the decision overturning the misconduct findings concerning those responses. [1]
This part of the judgment matters deeply to me. It concerns a professional's ability to challenge allegations, explain their position and question the process being used against them. My frustration was part of the record. So were my participation in the investigation and my apology. The appellate decisions examined those circumstances together. [1][2]
My criticism of the registrar became a particular of misconduct
The original allegation was broad. It concerned whether I had responded to complaints and criticism honestly, openly and courteously. Its particulars included comments I made about College officials, the way I defended my skills, and my criticism of the former registrar, Greg Eberhart. [2][3]
Allegation 5(j) specifically included my description of the registrar's complaint as an abuse of power and conflict of interest, together with my criticism of the length of his tenure. Those were my statements and opinions. Their inclusion in the misconduct case shows why I felt that my challenge to the process had itself become something I had to defend. [3]
I believed the concentration of authority deserved scrutiny. When a professional is already responding to a complaint from a senior regulatory official, criticism of that official can feel difficult to separate from the underlying case. I experienced the situation as personal. That is my account of how it felt, rather than a claim that the Court made a finding about anyone's private intentions.
What the Appeal Panel found missing from the original reasoning
In 2024, the Appeal Panel accepted the relevant factual findings about my comments but found the conclusion of unprofessional conduct unreasonable. It said the Tribunal had not properly considered the context. There was very little analysis of why internal comments made while defending allegations should amount to professional misconduct in these circumstances. [2]
At paragraph 260, the Panel said Allegation 5 came “dangerously close” to treating me as guilty because I refused to concede or understand the College's position. It emphasized that a regulated professional must have latitude to mount a defence and should not face additional findings simply for failing to make admissions. [2]
The Panel also observed that I had participated in the inspection and investigation. This was not a case of refusing to cooperate. It recognized that I had apologized following emotional comments about the registrar and questioned why the Tribunal had given that apology no meaningful place in its explanation. Those observations mattered because they restored context that the original findings had discounted. [2]
The Court explained the double-bind
The Court of Appeal upheld the reversal of the findings about my response to the investigation. It explained how the additional allegations could compromise my defence. If I described my training and skills to answer a challenge to my competence, that explanation could reinforce the allegation that I considered myself superior to other healthcare professionals. [1]
Similarly, if I pointed to advertising used by other pharmacists to explain why I believed my own advertising was acceptable, that comparison could reinforce an allegation that I was trying to justify my conduct instead of reflecting on it. The Court identified these examples when explaining the double-bind created by the case against me. [1]
That analysis captured something I had struggled to explain. I needed to answer the allegations with information about my education, experience and understanding of professional practice. Yet using that information could be treated as evidence of a problematic attitude. A fair process has to allow an answer to be assessed on its merits.
The fairness concern the Court actually identified
The Court said adding allegations arising from my response to the investigation raised significant fairness concerns. It also made a precise distinction: because those allegations were added before the hearing and disclosure was provided, I had not been deprived of notice or the opportunity to be heard in that sense. [1]
The concern was what happened to the substance of a defence when the professional also had to justify the way that defence was being advanced. The Court applied its earlier reasoning in Alsaadi, recognizing that the conduct of a defence will rarely properly become another disciplinary complaint. It also noted that obstruction or refusal to cooperate had not been alleged in my case. [1]
The judgment did not create immunity for everything a professional might say during an investigation. It explained why context and the opportunity to defend oneself matter, and why there can be good reasons to pursue allegations about the defence separately from the original complaint. [1]
My frustration and the limits of what the Court decided
The Court acknowledged that some of my comments could be criticized as rude or unproductive. It also said there was no evidence that College officers were acting from improper motives. I accept that those statements form part of the judgment I rely upon. My belief that I was being singled out cannot be presented as a judicial finding of bad faith. [1]
The Court nevertheless recognized that I was frustrated and hurt by allegations I perceived as singling me out and failing to recognize years spent developing my skills, including completing a doctorate. It upheld the conclusion that my responses, considered in context, did not amount to unprofessional conduct. [1]
I continue to believe that regulatory leadership should be open to questions about its decisions, its structures and its exercise of authority. My experience shows how much is at stake when disagreement becomes another allegation. A professional facing discipline needs a meaningful opportunity to challenge the case, and a regulator needs the discipline to examine that challenge fairly.
Sources and documents
[1] Al-Hallak v Alberta College of Pharmacy, 2025 ABCA 419. Judgment dated December 19, 2025, paragraphs 135–144. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.
[2] Appeal Panel of Council merits decision concerning Dr. Al-Hallak. February 23, 2024 decision, paragraphs 243 and 256–267; uploaded filename bears February 24.
[3] Hearing Tribunal decision on merits concerning Dr. Al-Hallak. November 29, 2022, printed page 8, Allegation 5(j).
Start the series: My ACP journey · Previous: When Explaining My Qualifications Became an Allegation