Skip to main content

ACPA – Alberta Cosmetic

By Dr. Kamal Alhallak, PhD | Part 10 of 10

The Alberta Court of Appeal’s December 2025 judgment changed the legal position in my case. Several findings were quashed, the reversal of findings concerning my response to the investigation was upheld, and specified professional-services allegations were sent back for reconsideration. One advertising finding remained. Existing sanctions and costs were also quashed and returned for reconsideration. [1]

That combination matters. The judgment was a substantial turning point, and it required further proceedings. This final article in the series explains what the later documents show, where the two legal disputes differ, and what I believe the College should learn from this experience.

Three findings the Complaints Director asked to have quashed

In its May 14, 2026 response submissions, the Complaints Director asked the new Appeal Panel to quash three further findings: allegation 1(b), concerning platelet-rich plasma; allegation 1(e), concerning uploads to Netcare; and allegation 4(d), concerning respect for other health professionals. These were express positions taken by the office prosecuting the case. [2]

The PRP allegation

For PRP, the Director accepted that the finding could not be sustained on the allegation as it had been framed. Its earlier position was that PRP fell outside pharmacy practice. After the Court’s interpretation, the Director acknowledged that it had not advanced evidence or pursued a finding on whether my provision of PRP met the regulatory framework’s requirements. [2]

That is a significant distinction. The question of professional scope had driven the allegation, but resolving that question did not create evidence about a different allegation. In my view, this illustrates why the wording of a charge and the evidence supporting it must remain central throughout a disciplinary case.

Netcare and the separate respect allegation

The Director also asked for the Netcare-upload finding to be quashed, accepting that the particular was circular because I could not have uploaded records from the clinic in the circumstances described. It said related conduct was addressed under another allegation. [2]

For allegation 4(d), the Director said there was an insufficient record to establish that the alleged conduct, considered alone, amounted to unprofessional conduct through a failure to respect other providers. It again pointed to a separate allegation addressing collaboration. These requests narrowed the positions being advanced; they did not amount to the Director abandoning every remaining allegation. [2]

What these concessions establish

I believe those changes deserve public attention because they show how far the case had moved from the original decision. By May 2026, the Director was itself asking for findings to be removed after the Court had required reconsideration. It nevertheless continued to seek findings on six professional-services particulars and sanctions relating to those matters and the advertising finding already sustained by the Court. [2]

The May documents record the Director’s position at that stage. A prosecutor’s request and a Panel’s decision are different steps in the process. By October, the College’s court filing confirmed that a later Council decision had been issued and appealed. The concessions in May must therefore be distinguished from the outcome of the subsequent decision and any further appeal. [5]

The changed position on costs and patient impact

The May submissions also stated that the Director was not seeking costs against me for the original hearing, the initial appeal or the remitted appeal. For a case that had begun with an order allocating approximately $354,639 in investigation and hearing costs to me, that change was substantial. It was a change in the Director’s requested remedy, which should be reported as such. [3] [7]

The Director further said it was not aware of any patients or members of the public being affected in the matter. In the same discussion, it maintained that the allegations demonstrated potential harm. Both parts belong in an accurate account. The statement supports describing the absence of identified affected patients in that submission; it does not establish that every possible safety concern had been resolved. [3]

My view is that proportionality requires close attention to actual evidence, the nature of any risk and the conduct established. Serious professional consequences should follow a clearly explained analysis of those matters.

A further appeal was recorded in October 2026

In its October 8, 2026 brief in the separate standards proceeding, the College stated that the remitted matter had returned to Council, that a new decision had been issued, and that I had appealed it to the Court of Appeal. It added that an appeal date had not then been set. [5]

The procedural position recorded in that filing shows that the dispute had continued through another decision and into a further appeal. My account here is tied to that October 8 record; the filing does not establish the outcome of the further appeal. [5]

For me, the additional appeal reflects the continuing importance of obtaining a legally sound resolution. The Court’s December 2025 conclusions provide the starting point for reviewing what followed.

The newer standards are a separate dispute

The College approved its newer standards in June 2024 for implementation in February 2025. They address, among other things, aesthetic injections in a regulated member’s professional capacity, the use of professional titles when offering certain services, and personal services in licensed pharmacies. My challenge to those standards is a separate Court of King’s Bench proceeding. [4]

The timing is important: those standards were adopted before the December 2025 appeal judgment. The judgment did not itself strike them down. In its October brief, the College argued that the standards were valid and that the earlier discipline judgment did not decide the newer case. That remains the College’s submitted position in the document. [4] [5]

I believe the Court’s interpretation of pharmacy practice raises important questions for that debate. I can make that argument while recognizing that the validity of the newer standards requires its own legal determination.

The reforms I want this experience to encourage

I want clearer guidance when pharmacists ask how their skills may be used in developing areas of practice. Where a proposed service raises legitimate concerns, the response should identify the concern, the evidence required and the applicable rule in language a practitioner can act on.

I also want a credible way to assess advanced competence. That discussion should consider training, assessment, emergency preparedness, documentation, collaboration and the limits of individual practice. Pharmacists with relevant experience should have a meaningful opportunity to contribute.

Finally, I want disciplinary processes that identify evidentiary weaknesses early, keep allegations precise, respect a member’s right to defend a case and explain how sanctions and expenditure serve the public interest. These are the lessons I draw from my experience.

The Court recognized my frustration and my perception of being singled out, while also stating that there was no evidence of improper motives by College officers. I can speak honestly about how this felt without turning an unproved motive into a fact. My case for reform rests on the documented decisions, the problems the Court identified, and the possibility of a more constructive relationship between the regulator and its members. [6]

Sources and documents

[1] Al-Hallak v Alberta College of Pharmacy, 2025 ABCA 419: final disposition. Paragraphs 144–153. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.

[2] Complaints Director’s response submissions, May 14, 2026: merits positions. Paragraphs 25, 54–57, 85–86, 109–110 and 136; PDF pages 7, 12, 17, 22 and 27.

[3] Complaints Director’s May 2026 positions on impact and costs. Paragraphs 123 and 134–138; PDF pages 25 and 27–28.

[4] College’s respondent’s brief, October 8, 2026: newer standards. Paragraphs 68–69; PDF page 21 / printed page 20.

[5] College’s October 2026 brief: distinct case and further disciplinary appeal. Paragraphs 113–118, especially 114; PDF pages 33–34.

[6] Court of Appeal’s assessment of the investigation-response context. Paragraphs 136–143, particularly 142–143. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.

[7] Appeal Panel merits decision, February 23, 2024: original costs order. Paragraph 19; printed page 4.

Start the series: My ACP journey · Previous: The Financial Cost of Defending My Professional Practice