Skip to main content

ACPA – Alberta Cosmetic

By Dr. Kamal Alhallak, PhD | Part 7 of 10

A disciplinary finding can have lasting consequences for a professional's livelihood and reputation. The evidence supporting it deserves equally serious attention. In my case, the Alberta Court of Appeal overturned findings concerning acne and compounded medication and rejected an incorrect interpretation of the recordkeeping standards. It also identified other evidentiary questions that required further consideration. [1]

Some findings were quashed by the Court itself. Other issues were returned to the College’s Appeal Panel without a final determination of the errors I alleged. [1]

The acne finding and the missing factual foundation

The Court examined whether the record established that I had prescribed, dispensed or administered medication to treat acne. It concluded there was no basis in the evidence before the Hearing Tribunal to make that finding. This was a fundamental problem because an allegation about how a medication was prescribed requires evidence that the relevant prescribing occurred. [1]

The judgment explained the gap. I had been asked about acne and hyperpigmentation and had acknowledged prescribing for hyperpigmentation. That answer did not establish that I had prescribed acne medication. No follow-up question confirmed it. The investigator's report described what would happen if I initiated acne therapy, but it did not identify sufficiently what initiating therapy meant or which medication was involved. [1]

These details may appear narrow to someone reading a summary of the case. For the professional facing the finding, they are essential. A statement about one type of treatment cannot simply establish another. A description of a possible practice does not, without sufficient evidence, prove the event alleged. The Court found that the Appeal Panel should have intervened. [1]

A general reference to compounded medication was insufficient

The Court identified a related problem with the references to compounded medications. Without identifying the nature of those medications and whether they were Schedule 1 drugs, the general reference could not reasonably establish that I had prescribed, dispensed or administered drugs in breach of my professional obligations. [1]

The practical point is straightforward. The treatment, the relevant obligation and the conduct said to breach it must be connected by evidence. The professional should be able to understand what particular act was proved and why it meets the standard for misconduct. I believed those connections had been missing, and the Court agreed in relation to these findings. [1]

At paragraph 87, the Court quashed the findings under Allegations 1(c) and 1(f) relating to acne and compounded medication. The reference to 1(c) needs care because that allegation also concerned Botox. The Botox-related issues were separately remitted for reconsideration. The Court did not dismiss every component of 1(c) through its decision on acne and compounded medication. [1]

The difference between documenting communication and keeping a fax

Another finding rested on my not retaining copies of fax notifications to other healthcare professionals. The Tribunal interpreted the standards as requiring the fax itself to be kept and treated its absence as a clear breach. The Court found that interpretation legally incorrect. [1]

The standards required a record of notification and appropriate documentation of communication and consultation. The Court explained that failure to retain the fax could be relevant when assessing whether the records were sufficient, but it did not determine the answer by itself. The obligation to maintain an adequate record could not automatically be reduced to possession of that particular document. [1]

I view that distinction as important for any professional working with digital records. Proper documentation remains necessary. The question is whether the record satisfies the applicable requirements in the circumstances. In my case, the Court rejected the categorical rule that had been used to support the finding. It did not declare every aspect of my recordkeeping adequate or remove the obligation to document care. [1]

The Court also questioned the evidence about PDO threads

The Court identified material questions about other findings, including the allegation concerning PDO threads not approved by Health Canada. It noted that the Tribunal relied on a receipt and an email identifying different possible sources, including particular unapproved brands. The Tribunal did not identify further evidence establishing that I had used those particular threads on patients, which I had denied. [1]

That passage matters because purchasing information, identifying available sources and proving a particular product was used on a patient are distinct evidentiary questions. The Court examined the reasoning connecting the documents to the conclusion about use. It also questioned the basis on which the Tribunal rejected my evidence on that issue. [1]

The Court nevertheless did not make a final finding that the threads I used were licensed or that this allegation necessarily had to fail. It returned the issue for the Appeal Panel to consider. I can rely on the Court's identification of weaknesses in the reasoning while remaining clear about the limit of what it decided. [1]

PRP and the significance of a single quotation

The Court also noted that the Tribunal's finding about assessing the appropriateness of PRP relied on a single quotation an investigator found on Health Canada's website. The quotation said Health Canada had not reviewed PRP's safety and efficacy for therapeutic purposes. The Court identified this as another example raising a question about the sufficiency of the evidence supporting the finding. [1]

At paragraph 69, the Court explained why it was sending these issues back. The record and arguments before it did not permit a conclusion that the Tribunal had made reviewable errors on those points. The Appeal Panel needed to consider them. This passage prevents the judgment from being described as a final dismissal of the PDO and PRP allegations. [1]

Why I insisted on examining the evidence

My concern throughout this process was that conclusions about my conduct were acquiring authority without the necessary examination of how they had been reached. The Court's findings on acne, compounded medication and fax records demonstrate why I continued to challenge them. The additional questions it identified explain why reconsideration was necessary. [1]

A large file does not answer an allegation merely by existing. Each significant finding needs support, and each professional obligation needs a sound legal interpretation. That is the standard I wanted applied to my case. I believe it is a standard every regulated professional should be able to expect, particularly when the consequences extend into their reputation and ability to work.

Sources and documents

[1] Al-Hallak v Alberta College of Pharmacy, 2025 ABCA 419. Judgment dated December 19, 2025, paragraphs 63–70, 74–87, 110, 121 and 147–148. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.

Start the series: My ACP journey · Previous: When Defending Myself Became Part of the Case Against Me