Skip to main content

ACPA – Alberta Cosmetic

By Dr. Kamal Alhallak, PhD | Part 3 of 10

The Court of Appeal recognized that I perceived the allegations against me as singling me out and failing to acknowledge the work I had put into my qualifications and skills. It also stated that there was no evidence that College officers acted from improper motives. Both points are part of the judgment, and both belong in an honest account of my experience. [1]

My personal experience was that the dispute became increasingly difficult to separate from the registrar's role. To explain that feeling, I want to set out what the hearing record actually establishes about Greg Eberhart's involvement, his longstanding position, and the way responsibilities were arranged inside the College.

A concern about public representation led to an inspection

Eberhart testified that he became aware of a concern in 2018 about how I represented myself publicly. He said Alberta Health contacted him in January 2019 after a person expressed dissatisfaction with the handling of a concern. He reviewed the Albany website and decided that further information was needed. He then requested an inspection of my practice at the cosmetic centre and of the associated pharmacy operations. [2]

That account matters because it identifies the point at which the registrar became directly involved. The initial issue concerned how my qualifications and services were presented. The inspection subsequently examined a much broader range of matters, including activities at the centre and the relationships between the businesses.

Eberhart explained that he considered an inquiry necessary to discharge his responsibilities. He also testified that he had requested many other inspections. I include that explanation because the fact that he initiated my inspection does not, by itself, establish that the decision was improper. [2]

The decision to request these inspections was his

One exchange in the hearing is especially clear. After Eberhart explained his role, counsel asked whether anyone else had been involved in making the decision to request the inspections. His answer was no. The transcript therefore establishes that he personally made that decision. [3]

There is a useful distinction here. Council formally appointed inspectors under the legislation; the registrar selected an appointed inspector to carry out this work. In my case, that inspector was Monty Stanowich. Eberhart said he wanted information about my practice and the relationship between the cosmetic centre and the pharmacies. [2]

Stanowich later confirmed that Eberhart chose him for the inspection. He also explained that his reporting relationship depended on the work he was doing: his direct supervisor was Deputy Registrar Jeff Whissell, but for an inspection he reported to the registrar who ordered it. [4]

The registrar later filed his own complaint

After the inspection and my response, Eberhart submitted a formal complaint dated September 3, 2019. The 2024 Appeal Panel decision records that sequence. His concerns included advertising, the presentation of my qualifications, prescribing and administering drugs, and whether some interventions were evidence-based and within pharmacists' scope. [5]

This was separate from the other complaint received on July 24, 2019. Jennifer Mosher was assigned to investigate both. The process therefore involved two complainants, one of whom was the College's registrar and had already initiated the inspections that produced a substantial part of the material under consideration. [5]

For me, that progression was important. The same senior official who had decided that my practice should be inspected then became a complainant within the organization responsible for regulating my professional registration. I wanted to understand what arrangements would ensure that each later decision was made independently.

What the reporting relationships showed

The Complaints Director, James Krempien, explained that he reported operationally to the deputy registrar. During cross-examination, he agreed that the deputy registrar reported to Eberhart and that Eberhart was, in that organizational sense, his supervisor's supervisor. [6]

These were real institutional connections. They were relevant to how I experienced the process and why I asked questions about independence. However, an organizational chart does not show who made a particular investigative decision or whether anyone exerted improper pressure. Krempien also explained that his responsibilities and authority arose under the Health Professions Act. [6]

Eberhart denied directing Krempien or Mosher about how to conduct the investigation. He described his later meeting with Mosher as an update provided to him in his capacity as complainant. Stanowich denied helping him draft his complaint. Those answers are part of the evidence and should be read alongside the reporting relationships. [3] [4]

Why his long tenure mattered to my view of the institution

In his evidence, Eberhart traced his leadership role back to becoming registrar designate of the Alberta Pharmaceutical Association in 1989 and registrar in January 1990. When the organization separated into regulatory and advocacy bodies in 2000, he became registrar of the College. He described contracts capable of renewal at Council's discretion. [7]

By the time of my hearing, that represented approximately three decades in a registrar role across the predecessor association and the College. I believe the length of that tenure is a legitimate subject of discussion when considering institutional culture and accountability. My concern is how a member can challenge an established approach when the same leadership has shaped the institution for so long.

I cannot infer an individual's motives from years of service. Long experience can bring valuable knowledge, and tenure alone proves nothing about my case. My personal view is that prolonged leadership makes visible checks, open disagreement, and meaningful routes for reviewing concerns particularly important. Those are the governance questions I wanted the process to answer.

Where my concern could be heard

The Tribunal records my testimony that I asked to meet the registrar and later the College's president because I felt unfairly treated. It records the president's position that a meeting would be inappropriate while the inspection was underway. The Appeal Panel separately recorded that my June 20, 2019 request for a cosmetic-practice framework received no response. [5] [8]

Those experiences contributed to my feeling that the process had become personal. I was raising questions about the approach taken toward me while the investigation continued through the same institution. I wanted a route through which those concerns could be examined without being treated simply as resistance to regulation.

The Court later upheld the reversal of the findings concerning how I responded to the investigation. It emphasized the context of my attempts to defend myself and the problems created when a professional must defend both the original allegations and the manner of responding to them. That conclusion is stronger and more precise than claiming that the Court found a personal campaign against me. [1]

The accountability question I take from this experience

My concern is that independence must be understandable to the person subject to the process. When a registrar initiates an inspection and later becomes a complainant, the member should be able to understand who is deciding each issue, how concerns about the inspection will be reviewed, and what prevents the registrar's institutional authority from influencing the complaint process.

The hearing record gives a factual basis for asking those questions. The Court's judgment provides the boundary for describing the outcome. Together, they allow me to explain why I felt targeted while keeping the discussion grounded in the actions, relationships, and decisions that can actually be examined.

Sources and documents

[1] Court of Appeal judgment, 2025 ABCA 419. Paragraphs 135–144, particularly 138–143. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.

[2] First hearing: Eberhart on origin and purpose of inspections. Transcript pages 621–625; PDF pages 715–719.

[3] First hearing: registrar's decision and later role. Transcript pages 631–636; PDF pages 725–730.

[4] Second hearing: Stanowich's appointment and reporting relationships. Transcript page 807 / PDF36; transcript pages 862–863 / PDF91–92.

[5] 2024 Appeal Panel merits decision: complaint sequence and framework request. Paragraphs 7–15; PDF pages 3–4.

[6] First hearing: Complaints Director's operational reporting. Transcript page 33 / PDF33; transcript page 147 / PDF147.

[7] First hearing: Eberhart's professional and registrar history. Transcript pages 616–618; PDF pages 710–712.

[8] 2022 Hearing Tribunal: requests for meetings. Paragraphs 201–202; PDF pages 47.

Start the series: My ACP journey · Previous: Before the Hearing, I Asked ACP for Guidance and a Framework