Skip to main content

ACPA – Alberta Cosmetic

By Dr. Kamal Alhallak, PhD | Part 4 of 10

The Court of Appeal's judgment allows me to describe an important distinction clearly. It recognized that I felt singled out and upheld the reversal of the findings concerning my response to the investigation. It also stated that the record contained no evidence of improper motives by College officers. I am writing about the facts that led me to question the process and about my experience of it, within that established outcome. [1]

My concerns involved the registrar's acquaintance with the other complainant, the relationship between the two investigations, and what happened when I asked for matters affecting independence to be examined. Those concerns were raised in the hearing, where the witnesses gave answers that can be checked against the transcripts.

The registrar acknowledged knowing the other complainant

Greg Eberhart acknowledged that he knew the other complainant professionally. He described a pharmacist–physician relationship when both practised in Red Deer, before he left that city in late 1989. He also described one later instance of correspondence about a complaint involving another pharmacist. [2]

This acknowledgement mattered to me because I had questioned whether there was an existing relationship between the two people who had complained about my practice. The hearing established a prior professional acquaintance. It did not establish that they were close friends or that they coordinated their complaints.

Eberhart expressly denied communicating with the other complainant about me. He said he had not seen or spoken to her since leaving Red Deer and described the later contact as correspondence. He also denied knowing, during his meeting with the investigator, that she was investigating two complaints. A fair account must include those answers. [2]

I asked for that concern to be examined

During Jennifer Mosher's testimony, she discussed my correspondence asking whether the registrar knew about the other complaint and whether the complainants were acquainted. When asked whether she had looked into the question, she said she had not. Her explanation was that she did not consider it relevant. [3]

I found that response significant. From my perspective, the question concerned confidence in the process itself. I wanted to know whether the two complaints were independent in their origin and how the registrar's position was being handled within the investigation.

Her answer does not prove that any communication occurred. It does establish that the question I raised was not investigated by her on the basis she gave. I asked for that concern to be examined; the investigator considered it outside the matters she needed to pursue.

The investigations shared material and witnesses

Mosher investigated both complaints. She explained that she tried to address each complainant's own concerns in their respective interviews, but did not separate the matters when interviewing me and other shared witnesses. After reviewing her notes, she acknowledged that information concerning PDO threads and PRP had been discussed with the registrar. [4]

She did not accept my suggestion that there had been no separation at all. She explained that some concerns overlapped and others differed. Later in the same testimony, she acknowledged that dispensing and Netcare concerns were not in the other complainant's original complaint. She said these became concerns during her investigation and that she believed she was obliged to investigate them. [4]

This helps explain why I found the process difficult to follow. There were two complainants, shared investigative material, and additional concerns arising as the work progressed. I wanted clarity about the source of each concern and the evidence supporting it. I believe that clarity is important when a professional must respond to a developing collection of allegations.

The investigator had not discussed a firewall

I asked Mosher whether she had discussed a firewall between the two complaints with the Complaints Director when she was assigned the registrar's complaint. She answered that she had not. She also said that she did not perceive a conflict because, in that matter, the registrar was the complainant. [5]

That evidence supports a question about how separation was considered. It does not establish that a particular firewall was legally required, or that combining related investigative work was necessarily improper. My concern was practical: how would the registrar's institutional role be kept distinct from his role as a complainant, and how would that distinction be made visible to me?

I also asked whether she felt compelled to follow a particular direction because Stanowich, a colleague, had already written a report. She answered no. She said she regarded him as professional and had no reason not to trust him. Those statements describe her position, while leaving me able to explain why independent scrutiny of the earlier report mattered to me. [5]

My concerns about the inspection were not the investigator's focus

The hearing also addressed declarations from my staff concerning the Westwood Pharmacy encounter. Mosher testified that she did not review them because activities at the pharmacy were not the focus of her investigation. [6]

Separately, Eberhart explained that he treated my complaint about Stanowich's conduct as an administrative matter. He said he reviewed the inspection report and my response and did not find sufficient evidence that Stanowich had acted inappropriately. [7]

From my position, these answers raised a difficult question about where my concerns could receive a substantive review. The registrar who had initiated the inspection assessed my complaint about the inspector, while the investigator pursuing the formal complaints did not consider the pharmacy encounter part of her focus. That sequence contributed to my feeling that my concerns about the process were not receiving a full examination.

What the witnesses denied

The evidence also has important limits. Eberhart denied directing either the Complaints Director or Mosher in the conduct of the investigation. Mosher denied that he personally instructed her to investigate inducements. She also denied a connection between her November meeting with him and a clarification request she sent the following day. [3] [7] [8]

Mosher said that the Complaints Director assigned investigations to her and gave feedback on her reports. She denied that either he or the registrar influenced her contract negotiations or renewal. These answers prevent an accurate account from treating her contractual relationship or the timing of a communication as proof of improper pressure. [8]

My personal view that the process felt directed against me arose from the combined experience of the relationships, unanswered questions, and decisions about what to examine. The Court did not adopt a conclusion that officials acted from improper motives. I do not convert my experience into such a finding.

Why raising these questions mattered

The Court's discussion of my defence is particularly meaningful here. It recognized the difficulty created when defending the original allegations could reinforce a further allegation about the manner of my defence. It upheld the reversal of the response-to-investigation findings after considering the context, including my frustration, the largely internal nature of the comments, and my apology. [1]

I believe members must have a workable way to raise concerns about independence and investigative choices. The response should make clear what was examined, what was not, and why. That would help both the institution and the member distinguish a disagreement about evidence from an allegation of personal hostility.

My account rests on that distinction. The hearing record explains why I questioned the process. Readers can consider the documented sequence and understand why confidence in a regulatory process requires more than an assurance that everyone has a different formal role.

Sources and documents

[1] Court of Appeal judgment, 2025 ABCA 419. Paragraphs 135–144, especially 138–143. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.

[2] First hearing: registrar's acquaintance with the other complainant. Transcript pages 634–635; PDF pages 728–729.

[3] Second hearing: inquiry about complainants' relationship. Transcript pages 1206–1207; PDF pages 508–509.

[4] Second hearing: separation, shared information, and new concerns. Transcript pages 1341–1344; PDF pages 678–681.

[5] Second hearing: firewall and influence questions. Transcript page 1348 / PDF685; transcript pages 1350–1351 / PDF687–688.

[6] Second hearing: staff declarations. Transcript page 1208, lines 7–13; PDF page 510.

[7] First hearing: registrar's role and administrative review. Transcript pages 632–638; PDF pages 726–732.

[8] Second hearing: timing and contractual arrangements. Transcript page 1221 / PDF523; transcript pages 1231–1235 / PDF533–537.

Start the series: My ACP journey · Previous: When the Registrar Became a Complainant in My Case