By Dr. Kamal Alhallak, PhD | Part 1 of 10
On December 19, 2025, the Alberta Court of Appeal issued its judgment in Al-Hallak v Alberta College of Pharmacy, 2025 ABCA 419. It overturned several findings of unprofessional conduct, upheld the reversal of findings about my response to the investigation, and returned other matters for reconsideration. Both my appeal and the College's cross-appeal succeeded in part. That decision is the starting point for this account because it establishes how the earlier disciplinary decisions must now be understood. [1]
The proceedings affected my professional life, finances, and confidence in the way concerns about my practice were being addressed. I want to explain how the case developed, why I continued challenging it, and what the documents actually establish. My personal experience belongs in that account. So do the findings that favoured me, the findings that did not, and the questions that remained unresolved.
What the Court of Appeal changed
The Court quashed findings concerning my alleged prescribing of acne and compounded medications. It also overturned findings about several aspects of my advertising and representations, including statements about my qualifications and my role leading a team at the clinic. These were consequential corrections to findings that had formed part of my professional disciplinary record. [1]
The judgment also upheld the Appeal Panel's decision that my response to the investigation did not amount to unprofessional conduct. The Court considered the context in which I had defended my qualifications and practice, including my frustration, the largely internal setting of the comments, and my apology. It described the difficulty created when defending the original allegations could reinforce additional allegations about the manner of my defence. [1]
There were limits to the result. The Court upheld an advertising finding concerning erectile dysfunction services that the clinic did not provide and claims about permanent and painless relief. It returned a number of professional-services issues to the Appeal Panel for further consideration. It also set aside the Appeal Panel's existing sanctions and costs, with those questions to be reconsidered after the outstanding merits issues. An accurate account must preserve those distinctions. [1]
Why I experienced the process as personal
As the case developed, I felt singled out. I became concerned about the former registrar's involvement, the concentration of authority within the organization, and the way my objections to the inspection and investigation were treated. Those concerns form part of my experience of the proceedings. They also led me to ask specific questions at the hearing about reporting relationships, the origins of the complaints, and the handling of concerns about independence.
The Court recognized that I was frustrated and hurt by allegations that I perceived as singling me out and failing to recognize the work I had put into my skills and competence. In the preceding paragraph, however, it expressly stated that there was no evidence that College officers were acting from improper motives or concerns. I cannot present the Court as having made a finding of personal targeting that it did not make. [1]
What I can do is explain the events that shaped my view and identify the evidence for each of them. Readers can examine the registrar's documented role, the testimony about organizational reporting, and the responses to the concerns I raised. That makes the account open to scrutiny rather than dependent on accepting my conclusions about another person's intentions.
The different roles within the proceedings
It is easy to describe everything in this history as something 'the College' did. The record is clearer when the different roles are identified. The registrar initiated the inspection process and subsequently became one of the complainants. The Complaints Director referred allegations to a hearing. The Hearing Tribunal made the original disciplinary findings. An Appeal Panel of Council reviewed those decisions, and the Court of Appeal later reviewed the Appeal Panel's decisions. [1] [2]
Those bodies did not take the same position on every issue. The College's internal Appeal Panel reversed significant findings in 2024. The Court later rejected part of that Panel's reasoning about the scope of pharmacy practice while overturning other findings that the Panel had upheld. The College itself succeeded on part of its cross-appeal. I will identify who made each decision and what happened to it on appeal, because a statement that was accepted at one stage may no longer represent the legal position. [1]
I had asked the College for a practice framework
One of the earlier events I want readers to understand is my request for a clearer approach to pharmacists' cosmetic practice. The 2024 Appeal Panel decision records that, on June 20, 2019, I wrote to the registrar asking the College to acknowledge and regulate pharmacists' role in cosmetic medicine and to work with other regulators and Alberta Health on the medical spa industry. It also records that I did not receive a response. [2]
That request matters to my account of why the later disciplinary process was so frustrating. I wanted the profession's role and the expectations of competent practice to be addressed directly. The ensuing case involved exactly the kinds of questions that made clear guidance important: which activities fell within professional practice, what obligations applied, and how those obligations should operate in the circumstances of a cosmetic clinic. [1] [2]
The consequences were substantial
The original June 2023 sanctions included a twelve-month suspension order, $35,000 in fines, and an order that I pay approximately $354,639 in investigation and hearing costs. The cost award was described as 70% of those costs, implying an underlying figure of approximately $506,627 for that stage alone. These were the original orders at that stage of the proceedings. Later appellate decisions altered the position. [2]
The Council and court appeals followed. In the financial article in this series, I distinguish the original costs, the later proceedings, my own defence expenses, and my estimate that cumulative College costs approached $1 million. The recorded order supplies a documented starting point; the cumulative estimate is my assessment, not an audited total established by the judgment.
The proceedings continued after the judgment
In May 2026, the Complaints Director asked for three of the remitted findings to be quashed and stated that it was not seeking costs against me for the hearing or the initial and remitted appeals. The Director continued to pursue other allegations. Those statements were submissions to the Appeal Panel and must be distinguished from the Panel's eventual decision. [3]
The College's October 8, 2026 court filing subsequently recorded that Council had issued a further decision and that I had appealed it to the Court of Appeal. That is a dated procedural fact, rather than a claim that this series establishes the outcome of every later step. My separate challenge to newer College standards also raises distinct issues; the December 2025 disciplinary judgment did not itself strike down those standards. [4]
What I want this account to contribute
I want readers to see the actual sequence: seeking guidance, experiencing an inspection, raising concerns about the process, facing disciplinary findings, and pursuing appeals that materially changed the record. The references throughout the series identify whether a statement comes from sworn testimony, a disciplinary decision, a party's submissions, or the Court's findings.
My experience has left me with questions about independent scrutiny of regulatory leadership, the evidence required for serious professional findings, the application of standards to developing areas of practice, and the financial consequences of prolonged proceedings. I am sharing the record so those questions can be considered with the same care that a regulator expects from the professionals it governs.
Sources and documents
[1] Al-Hallak v Alberta College of Pharmacy, 2025 ABCA 419. Paragraphs 1-11, 25, 62-70, 83-87, 109-124, 135-153. Read the Court of Appeal judgment.
[2] Appeal Panel merits decision dated February 23, 2024. Paragraphs 7-20, especially 12 and 19.
[3] Complaints Director response submissions on remitted matters dated May 14, 2026. Paragraphs 25, 54-57, 85-86, 109-110, 134.
[4] Respondent brief filed October 8, 2026. Paragraphs 68-69 and 114.
Read the complete ten-part series
1. Why I Am Telling My Story About the Alberta College of Pharmacy
2. Before the Hearing, I Asked ACP for Guidance and a Framework
3. When the Registrar Became a Complainant in My Case
4. Why I Questioned the Independence of the ACP Process
5. When Explaining My Qualifications Became an Allegation
6. When Defending Myself Became Part of the Case Against Me
7. The Evidence Behind a Finding of Professional Misconduct
8. What the Court of Appeal Actually Said About Pharmacists and Cosmetic Services
9. The Financial Cost of Defending My Professional Practice
10. After the Court of Appeal: What Changed and Why I Am Still Asking for Reform